Fall Out Boy- Take This To Your Grave
Here's something I'm starting because I've been more interested in writing about (and writing) music recently. Every weekend I'll have my album of the week on here and probably some other places as well, with an indepth track by track review of the album. This week's album is "Take This to Your Grave", Fall Out Boy's 2003 debut album. (yes, it's their debut. EOWYG doesn't count). Wikipedia classifies it as pop-punk and melodic hardcore. You can listen to it here:
https://youtu.be/6ULqIJ3p0RU. Fall Out Boy is Andy Hurley on drums, Patrick Stump on guitar and vocals, Joe Trohman on guitar, and Pete Wentz on bass and screams (for the early albums). Pete also writes most of the lyrics.
They announce their presence quickly on the opener "Tell That Mick He Just Made My List of Things to Do Today" with some slamming chords and then a very nice octave progression, a precursor to how often they use octave slides throughout their entire body of work. Fairly immature lyrics from Pete, but it was early (he was 24) and they're pretty funny, especially the way Patrick delivers them. His voice was still pretty nasally (more stereotypically pop-punk sounding) at this point, though he clearly has the chops that he's been refining ever since (check out their latest "American Beauty/American Psycho", especially the songs "Novocaine" and "Centuries". He's got PIPES).
In the next song, "Dead on Arrival", the "record" motif pops up for the first time in the catalog, in the chorus here, which they love using later on, as evidenced by "I've Got a Dark Alley and a Bad Ides That Says You Should Shut Your Mouth" from 2005's "From Under the Cork Tree" and "Favorite Record" from "American Beauty/American Psycho". This song gets incredibly repetitive, but that's something a lot of pop punk debut records suffer from, and even later records from some of the less original bands out there *cough*Blink-182*cough*.
Moving on from unfounded hatred on derivatively terrible bands, we move on to the next song, the classic, the one everyone knows: "Grand Theft Autumn/Where Is Your Boy". The one non "Saturday" song from this album they've played at almost every live show post-hiatus. Except, of course, the tour I saw, because why would they? My own annoyance at setlists aside, this is truly one of the greatest pop punk songs ever written, from that opening a capella (which Patrick was opposed to, I think we're all glad he went with it) to the quick power chords from Joe, to Pete's rumbling bass. Iconic, really.
"Saturday". Fall Out Boy loves this song, and I'm not entirely sure why. Don't get me wrong, it's a great song, but it's not a "close every show for the rest of our career with it" level great song. Maybe that honor should've gone to "Grand Theft Autumn". Pete does provide some really great screams in the background, which he does quite a bit on this album and the next two, with a bonus 2 line appearance on "West Coast Smoker" from 2008's "Folie á Deux". I like them, though I'm a big metal fan, so screams/growls/screeches don't bother me much anymore. I used to hate 'em though, don't ask about the first time I heard a Black Crown Initiate song...
Entering the middle of albums, especially pop punk ones, can always be a risky business. "Homesick at Space Camp", the next track, is decent, but nothing extraordinary. It kind of passes by without much ado. I will say that the bridge, with it's "these friends are, new friends are golden" refrain is very nice and can definitely hit close to home for a lot of the angsty pop punk crowd (including myself). The lull doesn't last, as the following song (with the charming title of "Sending Postcards From a Plane Crash (Wish You Were Here)") wastes no time in introducing itself with more angst: "I am such a sucker, and I'm always the last to know". While we're on the topic of words, let's take a second to memoralize pre-hiatus Fall Out Boy song titles. This one especially is up there with my personal favorites. It gets the point across perfectly, as do the lyrics, which again, fit perfectly in to many angsty teenagers lives, again including mine. Pete Wentz definitely has a gift for capturing certain things in his lyrics that manifested itself later in spades, but here there are occasional glimpses of the genius. Bonus points here go to the slightly bluesy breakdown and solo.
The next song, which some post-hiatus fans may recognize from a more recent song, "Chicago Is So Two Years Ago" also passes relatively without notice, other than the bridge section, which was sampled ten years later on Fall Out Boy's own "Save Rock and Roll". It's not even that great of a melody, though the way Pete's bass comes in under it is pretty cool. It does have a very cool ending transition (I'm a sucker for song transistions) to my favorite song on the album, "The Pros and Cons of Breathing" which starts off with a ridiculously and surprisingly emotive chord progression, flows into a catchy verse, and then makes it's way into Pete's most relatable chorus yet: "I want to hate you half as much as I hate myself". While they don't fit in musically as well with bands like My Chemical Romance and Panic! at the Disco, just listening to some of their early lyrics (and looking at early Pete Wentz, who brings the screams back here) it's easy to see how they got slammed with the "emo" label, which unfortunately tends to also shut most of the critical public off on them, as well as the other two bands I mentioned, who are both very solid bands (MCR slightly moreso than Panic!).
Fall Out Boy started their career off in the Chicago hardcore scene, which wasn't particularly acceptive of their more melodic and poppy direction. Here in "Grenade Jumper" they tribute their biggest and "only friend" whose name is -surprise!- Chris. It follows a pretty standard pattern for songs on this album (and many other pop punk songs, and I'm guilty of this as well on a couple songs) with the bar or two of one instrument to start before the entire band slams in together, but it has heart. We're entering the last parts of the album now, which can be another dead spot, and unfortunately they fall victim to it. They got through the middle with solid music, but as we enter here? The next song here is "Calm Before the Storm" and I'll be honest, before it came up on my listen through of the album to write this thing, I completely forgot this song existed. Listening to it again, it's not hard to see why. It has no real hook, and I can't remember the chorus melody while I'm literally still listening to the song. Some Pete screams come in to try to salvage it, but they can't really do much. This is a pretty short album (39 minutes), but I think overall it would've been better without this song. The next song's title ("Reinventing the Wheel to Run Myself Over") is promising, but it's another letdown. One of the best lines of the album in "18 going on extinct" is here in this song, but there's not much of a hook, and while the chord progression is decent, it's nothing really special. They definitely hit a late in the album slump here, but it's ok because "The Patron Saint of Liars and Fakes" is here. This has one of the best introductions in Fall Out Boy's catalog (odd since it closes the album) and a rather big sense of urgency and weight helps bring the album to a nice close, along with a great hook that makes you forget those last two songs ever even happened. Let's not ignore the absolutely gorgeous scream that leads into the last chorus, and the heaviness in the final chord that leaves you wanting nothing but more.
Overall a very good album. A couple of missteps, but nothing too terrible, and as pop-punk songs, they're gone pretty quickly and you can get to the next journey. If you don't know Fall Out Boy, check 'em out on Spotify, YouTube, iTunes, etc. and go see shows and such. They're one of my favorite bands, so I hope you guys like them.
If you liked this album, you may enjoy: Paramore, My Chemical Romance, All American Rejects
Top pair: The Pros and Cons of Breathing, Grand Theft Autumn/Where Is Your Boy
Album score: 68/100
I hope everyone enjoyed reading, if you have any comments on the album or the review, please comment and tell me. Next week I'll be writing about Muse's "The 2nd Law", so stick around for that. If you have any suggestions for an album I should review, please tell me and thanks for reading!